Does Your Advertising Make You Look Cheap? 6

I opened up the bright blue Val-Pack envelope this morning like I sometimes do, more out of a marketer’s curiosity than anything else.  I don’t use coupons; it’s too much of a hassle for me to save a few bucks.  But I do leaf through the coupons just to see who’s advertising, what they’re advertising, and if can find anything in there to blog about. Just kidding. That’s just and added bonus today!

So as I’m perusing endless pizza and car wash coupons  I noticed a huge difference in how the bigger companies advertised compared to the small local companies.

Holy cow – this is exactly what I am always ranting and raving about and here it is in print. In full color even!  Eureka, I’ve struck marketing consultant gold!

But before I get into analyzing the coupons, let’s see if you can spot the difference.  I’ll give you 60 seconds… Ready? GO…


OK, time’s up. What did you come up with???

Give up?

I can best sum it up in one word: VALUE.

Did you notice that the local companies automatically assumed that all we care about is PRICE? And the bigger national companies spoke to our need, want, or pain??? Do you see that?

Petrillo’s says:Professional Automotive Repair – For Less.”  Translation: We say we’re professional but we don’t expect you to pay us like professionals. We expect you to pay us less than you’d pay a professional…

Lucky Cleaners says : “Stop paying too much for dry cleaning… We’re the Finest Quality Cleaners in Town!”  Translation:  We are the finest quality cleaners in town, but we don’t expect you to pay us like we are.. you can pay us less than you pay the other, not-so-fine, not-so-quality cleaners.

Now in the real world, aren’t “quality” and “cheap” mutually exclusive? Really. Be honest. Think like a consumer not a business owner.  Can you really get quality and cheap?  Not usually. That’s why we buy name brands instead of generic and why we choose Starbucks coffee over McDonald’s, and Safeway over Food4Less.

Cheap to me says it’ll taste bad or it’ll break in a day. Quality says, it’s better, it’ll last a while.  So how can a company be “quality” and cheap?  It can’t.

Now compare that messaging to what the national companies say:

Sports Authority: “Got what you need for Spring? Find all the gear you want here…”  Translation: We know what you need and we know you’re willing to pay for it.  But because this is Valpak and you expect it, we’ll give you 20% off. But nowhere does it say, “Shop us because we’re cheap” – And anyone who has shopped there knows that even with 20% off, it’s far from cheap.

Anderson Windows:Why deflate your home’s value with cheap, ugly windows?”   Translation: You don’t want your home to look ugly do you? So then why would you buy cheap windows?  We charge more – but we know you’ll pay it because you want to protect the value of your home and you don’t want ugly windows.

Lesson: 

The bigger companies understand VALUE.  They understand that when they communicate to potential customers in their words, on their terms, and with products and services they really need they don’t have to be the cheapest to get their business.

The reason I do what I do is because I’ve worked with huge multinational corporations and I’ve worked with small companies and I wanted to take the tools and practices that the huge companies use and teach small businesses how to stop wasting money chasing bad marketing.  This example makes that point perfectly.

Doing the groundwork is crucial. Studying your customers, your competition, and your market are fundamentals.  Knowing your target market and why they buy what they buy is critical. Figuring out how you’re different from your competition is essential. And learning how to communicate these things effectively is mandatory. Or you will always have to fall back on price.  Who wants to compete on price? Who wants to be CHEAP?  Wouldn’t you rather charge what you’re really worth and be known as the Quality company?

What does your advertising say about your company? Tell us!

  • http://www.averagepersongardening.com Mike the Gardener

    Wow! Never thought of it that way. I am guilty of the cheap & quality type of ad as well. Thanks for this information.

    • http://www.FortuneMarketingCompany.com Carolyn Higgins

      Mike -

      I’m glad you found it helpful! Thank you very much for letting me know it helped. I love that!!! :-) Take care and happy advertising!

      -Carolyn

  • Larry

    You might be great with marketing – but you need a proof reader. In the first paragraph you say: That’s just and added bonus today! Should be “That’s just an added bonus today!”

    Good article though….

    • http://www.FortuneMarketingCompany.com Carolyn Higgins

      Larry – Wow, only one typo? I’m elated! :-P Thanks for reading and the comment. – Carolyn

  • Tung

    I think people looking through a coupons book mostly look for cheap deals. Regardless of the point of the article and the point of the one ad focused on value, the three cheap looking company ads are actually the ones designed correctly for the cheap audience. More clutter = cheap. As a person flipping through the coupons book, I don’t think you’d stop for the elegantly designed ad, which is why APPLE, Mercedes, Gucci don’t show up in coupon books.

    • Dave Cannon

      This is a great point, and it brings up the importance of A/B testing. Maybe try different copy – one that emphasizes the low price and another that highlights the product quality.

      Has anyone used ValPak for this? What worked for you?

About the Author Carolyn Higgins is the President and founder of Fortune Marketing Company. You can follow her on Google+. Read more »

How LivePlan makes your business more successful

LivePlan: Online Business Planning Software

If you're writing a business plan, you're in luck. Online business planning software makes it easier than ever before to put together a business plan for your business.

As you'll see in a moment, LivePlan is more than just business plan software, though. It's a knowledgable guide combined with a professional designer coupled with a financial wizard. It'll help you get over the three most common business hurdles with ease.

Let's take a look at those common hurdles, and see how producing a top-notch business plan sets your business up for success.

Click to continue
RATE THIS ARTICLE 1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars
Loading ... Loading ...